A Study On Milgram s On Ethics Essay - 1601 Words

Milgram on Ethics A Study on Where Milgram Crossed the Line Kyle Froerer Weber State University Upon researching Milgram’s study more in depth and weighing the opinions of those who feel it is an ethical study versus those in opposition I add my opinion to those who feel the experiment was an unethical practice. This paper will explain more of why I feel this way. I will also provide four peer reviewed sources supporting my argument. The first reason I find it to be unethical is because of the ways in which subjects were lured into participating in the study. Certain people could say they volunteered but that would require they not be compensated for their efforts in any way. Each participant was financially compensated with $4.50 which is the equivalent of about $25.00 to today’s currency (Dollar Times, 2008). Because none of the participants were truly volunteers their actions and subsequent test results must not be considered ethically accurate when comparing them to society in general. Continuing on, the setting in which the participants were observed was a foreign setting all with employing behaviors unique to that of a scientist (Baurimd, 1964). Now, coupling the foreign setting, strange behaviors and the fact they have been paid with the principle of participant obedience, it can be assumed that all these attributes mixed together would result in an overly obedient test subject. To accurately study the baseline for the principle of obedience inShow MoreRelatedReview Of Stanley Milgram s Obedience Essay1620 Words   |  7 Pagesperson. According to Milgram, an alarming amount of subjects willingly proceeded to the highest voltage shock in the experiment. In Baumrind s†¯Review of Stanley Milgram s Experiments on Obedience, she attempts to disprove and refute Milgram s experimen ts by criticizing his experimental set-up, his†¯lack of safety precautions, his ethically questionable study, and his comparison between his experiments and Nazi Germany. In Parker’s â€Å"Obedience,† he seeks to show Milgram s strengths and weaknessesRead MoreStanley Milgram s Research On Obedience863 Words   |  4 PagesStanley Milgram s groundbreaking studies on obedience certainly shocked the world with their electrifying results. The experiment that Milgram conducted included ordinary people delivering â€Å"shocks† to an unknown subject, which caused much controversy to occur and raised many questions in the psychological world. Diana Baumrind, a psychologist at the University of California and one of Milgram’s colleagues, attacks Milgram’s ethics in her review. She decides that Milgram s tests are unethical towardsRead MoreAnalysis Of Stanley Milgram s Perils Of Obedience Essay1709 Words   |  7 PagesStanley Milgram, an American psychologist, questions the social norm in â€Å"Perils of Obedience† (1964), where he conducted a study to test how far the average American was willing to for under the pressures of an authority figure. Milgram s study showed that under the orders of an authoritative figure, 64% of average Americans had the capability of projecting voluntary harm on another person. Nonetheless, Diana Baumrind, an American developmental psychologist, argues in â€Å"Some Thoughts on Ethics of Research:Read MoreThe Milgram Experiment1142 Words   |  5 PagesThe Milgram Experiment Stanley Milgram, a famous social psychologist, and student of Solomon Asch, conducted a controversial experiment in 1961, investigating obedience to authority (1974). The experiment was held to see if a subject would do something an authority figure tells them, even if it conflicts with their personal beliefs and morals. He even once said, The social psychology of this century reveals a major lesson: often it is not so much the kind of person a man is as the kind of situationRead MoreOutline the Simalarities and Differences Between Milgrams (1963) Obedience Study and Burgers (2009) Replication1550 Words   |  7 PagesKaren Bullen R2208481 DE 100 Investigating Psychology 1 TMA02 Outline the similarities and differences between Milgrams (1963) obedience study and Burgers (2009) replication. This essay will look at an important key psychological experiment carried out by the renowned social psychologist Stanley Milgram which was carried out in the early 1960’s (Banyard 2012) to determine how far ordinary people would go to inflict pain to a fellow human based on instruction from an authority figure, andRead MoreThe Impact Of Technology On The Development Of Psychological Research1462 Words   |  6 Pagessurrounding the ethics of the study by Milgram, into obedience, and how, in light of new ethics guidelines, technology has enabled his study to be replicated and extended. Then, it will consider the work of both Broca and Wernicke, and looks at how they came to their findings without the aid of technology, how technology has since confirmed their findings, and how it extended their studies. After this, the essay will look at studies into friendship, how technology could be used in future studies and theRead MoreMilgram’s Study of Obedience to Authority772 Words   |  3 Pagesethical issues relating to it. Before outlining Milgram’s experiment this essay will look at Milgram himself. ‘Stanley Milgram was born in New York in 1933. A graduate of Queens College and Harvard University, he taught social psychology at Yale and Harvard Universities before become a Distinguished Professor at the Graduate Centre of the City University Of New York.’ (Zimbardo, 2010) Milgram’s study of obedience was an experiment that looked at how ‘ordinary citizens obey the orders of anRead MoreThe Theory Of Psychology And Psychology Essay971 Words   |  4 PagesPsychology is the scientific studies of the human mind, functions and their behavior Psychology primarily focus on those demonstrating behavior in certain given context, seeking to understand And explain thoughts, emotions and behaviors. Research psychologist studies exciting opportunities in psychology; it looks at various branches in the field of psychological research, for example in clinical psychology which includes both scientific research, focusing on the search for general principles, andRead MoreHistory Of Obedience And Conformity1729 Words   |  7 Pagesutterance of â€Å"research in obedience,† Stanley Milgram is the epithet in social psychology. 56 years ago, Milgram tested the limits of a person s ability to commit deeds that would normally be directionally challenging to their moral compass when commanded to act by an authority figure. Just 15 years after the World War II Holocaust, the Milgram experiments was a social psychology response to a topic of â€Å"particular relevance† during that time (Milgram, 1963): Were Nazi officers following orders orRead MoreConflict Between Obedience And Authority And Personal Morale1226 Words   |  5 Pa geshimself as an instrument for carrying out another person s wishes and he therefore no longer regards himself as responsible for his actions.† ( ) When one thinks of the many historical events, it is evident that much of humans behaviour is a result of obedience to authority in contrast to rebellion. Why is this? One and possibly the most famous experiment ever executed to investigate this moral question is referred to as â€Å"The Milgram experiment.† We hear and come across commands and orders